Ga door naar hoofdinhoud

Model A1311 / Late 2009 / 3.06 or 3.33 GHz Core 2 Duo processor

259 Vragen Bekijk alle

Can a 2009 core 2 duo logic board be replaced with a 2010 i3 board?

Hello, I purchased as a project one iMac late 2009 A1311 Core 2 Duo CPU EMC 2308 that have a toasted logic board, the part number is 820-2494-A

Block Image

Block Image

Searching in ebay, found that the C2D boards are very expensive, a i3 logic board for a mid 2010 A1311 part number 820-2784-A is pretty similar in shape, screw location and connectors, the angle of the power cable connector is different, everything else looks the same.

Block Image

Block Image

Anyone had tried a logic board swap? I know that have to buy a new CPU and probably a GPU, but the cost is about the same buying only the C2D logic board or the i3 logic board + i3-550 cpu.

The GPU is other issue, because I don't know how the integrated graphics works in the i3-550, but I have a spare HD2600 PRO that I can use if necessary.

Is it possible? or maybe I'm complicating too much and should just sell the iMac as parts?

Beantwoord! View the answer Dit probleem heb ik ook

Is dit een goede vraag?

Score 5
Een opmerking toevoegen

3 Antwoorden

Gekozen oplossing

The short answer is: YES YOU CAN replace a 2009 C2D logic board with a 2010 i3 one

The long answer:

I'm in the process of make this Frankenstein's iMac, and I already can hear the villagers with torches and forks coming here, but had to made it in name of apple science, I got a working 820-2784-A logic board from a fresh deceased 2011 iMac (I don't know where it comes, I don't wanna ask) with IR receiver, wifi/bluetooth module, videocard, and CPU with booth coolers for the same cost of the 820-2494-A C2D motherboard, I was really, really lucky. Phisically the logic board fits in the aluminium housing with no problem.

The cables for accesories and connectors is another thing. This is the list of connectors that are different or have no place to plug in:

*Power button cable have to be re-routed so it can reach the connector

*SD card reader cable 593-1041 have to be replaced with a cable 593-1223

*Wifi/bluetooth antenas cables need to be re-reuted

*Wfi/bluettoth cable 593-1079 is no longer needed

*820-2566 support for the wifi/bluetooth module is no longer needed neither

*LCD signal cable 593-1006 is different, need a 593-1280

*CPU fan connector is different, you need the fan 610-0094 with temp sensor

*Headphones and rear mic connector 593-1086 is different, needs the cable 593-1231

*Camera cable 922-8829 is different, needs the 593-1218-A cable with temp sensor

*ODD temp sensor 593-1152 is different, needs a 593-1242

I found someone selling his 2010 iMac for pieces, so I'll try to get all that parts for cheap in one place, if I can sell the pieces that I don't need, the transplants for the Frankenstein's iMac could be free...

Next step: upgrade the i3 540 with a i5 680

Was dit antwoord nuttig?

Score 7

Commentaar:

Did it work?

Was replacing all cables really necessary?

I have a 2009 c2d 21.5" that I would love to upgrade to i5 or i7

door

Eze, yes it worked, and all those new cables are needed, because many of the existing cable connectors are not compatible with the new otherboard.

I recommend you to do as I, look for many reference images of the motherboard compatible with the CPU you want to install and compare the connections with the existing connections on your motherboard, so you will see which cables can be re-used and which cables you should change, if you choose the same motherboard than me, then most of the research work is already done.

door

Alfredo Hola!! Great job on this upgrade. One question (for now lol!!) if you changed lcd signal cable to 593-1280 but with 2009 lcd screen, how did you make it work as pn 593-1280 connector lcd side is different than the 2009?

Thx!!

door

Een opmerking toevoegen

I’ve completed the conversion myself also. I had an ATI Radeon HD 5670, 512MB, GPU that I took out from a 2010 iMac I upgraded to a 2011 GPU. I realized after looking, that there was not too high of a cost to then convert my 2009 3.33 Core 2 Duo to a 2010 logic board. I also had a i5-680 CPU that could be used as I had upgraded the 2010 iMac to an i7-860S. For the conversion, I ran into some issues not quite listed above. Here’s all the parts I needed:

2010 Logic Board, I used part number 820-2784-A which is also 661-5534

2010 SD card reader cable PN: 593-1223 (also found under 922-9430)

2010 video card pressure wall PN: 922-9483 (this is a plastic piece that attaches to the logic board and helps ensure air cycles to the GPU cooler fins)

2010 Bluetooth, camera and sensor cable with the ambient temp sensor integrated is actually PN: 922-9366. The PN: 593-1218-A the previous contributor mentioned is for the 2011 model, which can be used as long as use the 2011 iSight camera PN: 922-9494 (the connector on the camera is different on the 2011 harness)

2010 Audio ports (headphones and mic) PN: 593-1231

2010 Optical drive cable PN: 593-1243 (on the 2009 the logic board connector is one solid, in-line piece. on the 2010 there are two separate connectors on the logic board)

2010 Optical drive temp sensor PN: 593-1242

2010 CPU fan PN: 610-0094

I was able to get all the parts listed above for $114. This listing and price doesn’t include the GPU as I already had that. The logic board I got came with 4GB of RAM, otherwise you may have to account for that. I’ve upped it to 16GB. It also does not account for the i5-680 CPU chipset, which I found for ~$40. You can also use the i7-860S chipset if desired, the actual 2010 iMac I have I used that for and found it for ~$75. There is also a i7-870S chipset that works, but is rare so the price is much higher.

As discussed by the previous contributor, I tried swapping the connector on my existing LCD screen (PN: 922-9497). However the display did not work. I had to get a 2010 LCD screen PN: 805-9684 and the backlight inverter PN: 612-0073, which was needed as it has a different connector to the LCD screen. This added $97 to my cost. I may just not have had luck like the previous contributor in getting it to work.

Once converted, your ‘About This Mac’ information will change to match the new logic board. Here’s what my 2009 iMac shows now:

Block Image

Here’s some benchmark scores from my modding as well:

The 2009 21.5 iMac before converting. Had 3.33 GHz Core 2 Duo CPU -> https://browser.geekbench.com/v4/cpu/114...

The 2009 21.5 iMac after installing the 2010 logic board, 3.6GHz i5-680 (2 core) CPU -> https://browser.geekbench.com/v4/cpu/119... & ATI Radeon HD 5670 (512MB) GPU -> https://browser.geekbench.com/v4/compute...

With the 2010 logic board, you can push the limits a bit more as well. For example I have a 2010 21.5 iMac that I installed the 2.53 GHz i7-860S (4 core) CPU -> https://browser.geekbench.com/v4/cpu/115... Also, as mentioned, the 2010 logic board can take the 2011 21.5 iMac’s ATI Radeon HD 6770M (512MB) GPU -> https://browser.geekbench.com/v4/compute...

An advantage of the i7 chipset is that you can take advantage of 32GB RAM as well! Here’s the ‘About This Mac’ for our actual 2010 iMac with those mods:

Block Image

Was dit antwoord nuttig?

Score 3

Commentaar:

Hi. Looking at my 2009 CPU fan (PN 610-0029) it looks a lot like the 2010 model you recommend (PN 610-0094). How different would they be and will there be fitment issues as Im planning on using my 21.5 late 2009 shell but with a 2010 logic board, just like you did.

Thanks in advance!!

door

As Alfredo Morales stated in his post, the CPU fans have different connectors on the 2009 and 2010 models. The 2010 model has the fan and a temp sensor. It'll throw you off when you disassemble the 2009 because there is a temp sensor that clips into a retainer on the fan, but that's the ambient temp sensor the 2009 uses and is on it's own connector. That's why you have to get the 2010 bluetooth/ambient temp sensor/camera harness since they share a connector on the 2010. Also, the 2010 ambient temp sensor gets routed to the top of the case.

As far as I can tell, the 2010 uses those two temp sensors, which provides a good delta of air temp coming in and going out.

door

Ok thanks, As of now Im trying to source the parts for my conversion. How is your upgraded model running so far?

Thx again.

door

Can I use the late 2009 GPU heatsink on the 2010 logicboard? My 2009 came with the Nvidia soldered card, but I might be able to get the Heatsink from the other late 2009 model which came with ATI Radeon 4670, and then use the 5670 GPU as an upgrade?

door

Good morning Brian. If Im planning on having a Fusion drive setup, do I need the 2010 Optical drive temp sensor PN: 593-1242? Thx!!

door

3 commentaren meer tonen

Een opmerking toevoegen

Thanks for taking the time for posting such an elaborate answer !

Was dit antwoord nuttig?

Score 0
Een opmerking toevoegen

Voeg je antwoord toe

Alfredo Morales zal eeuwig dankbaar zijn.
Weergavestatistieken:

Afgelopen 24 Uren: 3

Afgelopen 7 Dagen: 21

Afgelopen 30 Dagen: 87

Altijd: 688