Third party battery replacement different wire colors?

Recently pulled this old Zune out of storage and attempted to replace the battery with a supposed 'like new' third party one. Getting in and doing the soldering work was a breeze with the instructions here. However I'm still not getting the Zune to boot up.

The third party battery did have a different wire color. Red, White, Black, and Green compared to Red, White, Black, and Blue on the original. All were soldered to the same place with Green in the same places as Blue originally.

Anyone else had any luck with these and getting the Zune to boot up?