I already found the fix.
So I hard reset the Apple Watch. I held down the scroll wheel & the power button for ~15 seconds. It stayed on the Apple Logo for 30 seconds - 1 minute like I stated above. ONCE the Apple logo disappeared, I clicked the Power Button and the Apple Logo came on and I immediatly held down the scroll wheel ONLY for about 10 seconds. It then booted normally.
I tried this method after I took off the replacement screen and put the broken original screen back on. The original broken screen gave me the same exact issues as the replacement.
Thats the exact steps I used on getting my Apple Watch Series 1 to stop freezing on the Apple Logo.